Pam, I'd like to answer your question. My husband's physician bills an E/M every time my husband goes in for his annual physical (he has depression and non-esstential tremors). Every time we request the notes and I review them there is never enough documentation to support the office visit. Basically he notes depression stable, tremors still present and renews the prescriptions.
How do we feel about this? Personally it makes me angry. The physician is not doing anything outside or over and above what he would do for the physical but trying to make more money. One year he was charged for an ECG when all the doc did was re-read his previous one. It also makes me think, if I know what's required, how many people who don't know is he doing this with? I feel that unless the patient's "other problems" take a significant amount of time (and stable chorinc problems shouldn't) then there is no reason to bill an E/M with an annual wellness visit.
I realize that payments are being reduced and the physicians need to find revenue to stay in business, but as you stated, there is the issue of patient satisfaction. I've told my husband to find a new doctor, but he likes this one so he won't switch so every year I have my fight with the billing dept. I would have left the practice a long time ago.