Home Health & Hospice Week
Laws Other Than HIPAA May Launch Patient Privacy Lawsuits
HIPAA isn’t your only compliance wor-ry when it comes to patients’ health information. Plaintiffs are filing lawsuits — and winning settlements — against health care providers for data breaches under other federal and state laws.
After the billing vouchers of more than 13,000 patients went missing from an off-site storage vendor, plaintiffs filed a class action lawsuit against the University of Miami Health System. The vouchers included patients’ names, dates of birth, Social Security numbers, physician names, insurance company names, medical record numbers, and procedure and diagnostic codes.
UMHS has requested that a Florida judge approve a proposed settlement in the class action lawsuit, according to attorney Linn Foster Freed-man in a post for law firm Nixon Peabody. Under the settlement agreement, UMHS will pay $100,000 in individual claims, $90,000 in attorneys’ fees, and $1,500 to the named plaintiff. UMHS would also conduct risk assessments and remediation.
What’s especially curious about this lawsuit is that the plaintiff filed the action under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Florida state law, alleging that she suffered financial harm because money was withdrawn from her bank account following the breach, Freedman states. “This is the first time we have seen a settlement by a health system for a data breach under the FCRA, nor do we see how the FCRA can be relevant to the facts of this case.”
Moreover, patients’ financial information does not appear to have been included in the breached data from the billing vouchers.
Warning: “This settlement is an unfortunate precedent on two levels — first, it appears to be a settlement under the FCRA, which is a first to our knowledge,” Freedman states. “And second, it is a settlement of a case where there does not appear to be any relationship between the data breach and the alleged harm and where the attorneys received almost as much as the settlement on the merits.”
Bottom line: “Opening these doors in the data breach arena is discouraging,” Freedman concludes.
Home Health & Hospice Week
- Compliance:
CMS Proposes Revised COPs
‘Dramatic changes’ ahead for Conditions of Participation. Nearly 20 years ago, Medicare proposed changes to [...] - Regulations:
Get Ready For These Major Changes To The COPs
Expect finalization of the COPs next year. The first changes to the home health COPs [...] - Quality Improvement:
Roll Up Your Sleeves For Some Serious QAPI Work
Proposed COP revisions contain more than just tweaks. Leave space in your calendar for COP [...] - Compliance:
COP Proposal Contains Some Pluses
Sixty-day summary change should please while discharge proposal is impossible. The newly proposed revisions to [...] - Documentation:
Beef Up Clinical Records Or Risk Deficiencies Under New COPs
Make sure your records contain these 6 proposed elements. How robust are your clinical records? [...] - Regulations:
Beware This Discharge Provision In New COPs
Aide and HIPAA changes may bring new headaches, too. At first glance, the proposed Conditions [...] - Labor Law:
Don't Let Exemption Delay Lure You Into Lawsuits
DOL puts off enforcement 6 months. Elimination of the companionship exemption to minimum wage and [...] - Industry Notes:
High-Therapy Claims Rack Up More Denials
Twenty-plus therapy visits are a red flag. Face-to-face and OASIS problems continue to dog high-therapy [...] - Industry Notes:
New F2F-Focused Review Underway, Trade Group Says
Thought you’d seen the last of scrutiny for face-to-face claims, now that the physician narrative [...] - Industry Notes:
IMPACT Law To Bring Data Changes As Well As More Frequent Hospice Surveys
Watch for efforts to standardize the patient data you collect across post-acute care settings, now [...] - Industry Notes:
Watch This Reason For Bogus Claims Suspensions
If you’re having trouble with claims suspending with reason code E4502, you’ll have to wait [...] - Industry Notes:
Laws Other Than HIPAA May Launch Patient Privacy Lawsuits
HIPAA isn’t your only compliance wor-ry when it comes to patients’ health information. Plaintiffs are [...]
